AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
Moderator: Post Moderators
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
Ok, got my scoresheets back today: 31,29,30 for a total of 30. It did better at the batch 50 comp, but still not good enough to win.
These judges all commented on too much alcohol flavor, which none of the batch 50 judges noticed. They also all commented on a little bit of astringency which one of the batch 50 judges picked up on (not the Master ranked judge though ). They said there was little to no belgian character, which is the opposite of what the batch 50 judges said. Oh well, it's interesting to see how different judges react to the same beer. At least they all said they enjoyed it.
The basic comments on all the scoresheets point to one thing that needs to be changed: it needs more body. The yeast I used just chewed through everything and left it very dry. I find that pretty nice, but I can see why it might bother them. More oats should take care of that.
These judges all commented on too much alcohol flavor, which none of the batch 50 judges noticed. They also all commented on a little bit of astringency which one of the batch 50 judges picked up on (not the Master ranked judge though ). They said there was little to no belgian character, which is the opposite of what the batch 50 judges said. Oh well, it's interesting to see how different judges react to the same beer. At least they all said they enjoyed it.
The basic comments on all the scoresheets point to one thing that needs to be changed: it needs more body. The yeast I used just chewed through everything and left it very dry. I find that pretty nice, but I can see why it might bother them. More oats should take care of that.
- brew captain
- Posts: 1158
- Joined: Sat Oct 01, 2005 8:41 am
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
Awesome feedback Brent! Thanks again...
Now let's talk about the March club only entry. Dan, you up for entering that Tripel in the name of the club? Anybody else have a strong ale in the categories identified for consideration?
Cheers!
Now let's talk about the March club only entry. Dan, you up for entering that Tripel in the name of the club? Anybody else have a strong ale in the categories identified for consideration?
Cheers!
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
I have a Belgian Dark Strong ... not a Trippel ... but I'm surely willing to enter it .. let me know!brew captain wrote:Awesome feedback Brent! Thanks again...
Now let's talk about the March club only entry. Dan, you up for entering that Tripel in the name of the club? Anybody else have a strong ale in the categories identified for consideration?
Cheers!
Dan
- brew captain
- Posts: 1158
- Joined: Sat Oct 01, 2005 8:41 am
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
For the moment Dan - tag you're it!!
Thanks!
Cheers!
Thanks!
Cheers!
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
OK ... it did well at Pac Brewer's Cup but not so well at the Batch 50 comp.brew captain wrote:For the moment Dan - tag you're it!!
Thanks!
Cheers!
Let me have a look at the comp info and get it ready to go. When is the final decision date?
Dan
- brew captain
- Posts: 1158
- Joined: Sat Oct 01, 2005 8:41 am
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
Here you go Dan...brew captain wrote: March/April 2009
Beers with OG > 1.080
Entries are due March 28, 2009. Judging will be held Saturday April 4, 2009. Entry fee is $7. Make checks payable to American Homebrewers Association.
Entry Shipping:
AHA COC
The Country Cannery
1320 1st Ave. N.
Moorhead, MN 56560
Hosted by Susan Ruud and the Prairie Homebrewing Companions of Fargo, ND, this competition covers beer styles in the following table.
BJCP Category Style
5C, D Dopplebock, Eisbock
9E Strong Scottish Ale
12C Baltic Porter
13F Imperial Stout
14C Imperial IPA
15C Weizenbock
16C, D, E Siason, Bière de Garde, Belgian Specialty Ale
18C, D, E Belgian Tripel, Belgian Golden Strong Ale, Belgian Dark Strong Ale
19A, B, C Old Ale, English Barleywine, American Barleywine
20 Fruit Beer over 1.080 OG
21 Spice/Herb/Vegetable Beer over 1.080 OG
22B, C Other Smoked Beer over 1.080 OG, Wood-Aged Beer over 1.080 OG
23 Specialty Beer over 1.080 OG
For more information, contact Susan Ruud at Susan.Ruud@ndsu.nodak.edu.
Cheers!
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
Thanks BC.
So I'll be looking to get it shipped somewhere around Mid March ... that leaves 6 weeks for you to change your mind!
Dan
So I'll be looking to get it shipped somewhere around Mid March ... that leaves 6 weeks for you to change your mind!
Dan
- brew captain
- Posts: 1158
- Joined: Sat Oct 01, 2005 8:41 am
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
I must admit that I have a very nice Tripel that is almost a year old, but I am dubious that I have enough left to fill even one bottle let alone two. I swear that keg should have blown ten pints ago, but it keeps on keeping on.
Of course now that I need to fill a couple bottles I am sure it will blow foam the instant I depress the tap handle next...
Anybody else got a conforming beer?
Cheers!
Of course now that I need to fill a couple bottles I am sure it will blow foam the instant I depress the tap handle next...
Anybody else got a conforming beer?
Cheers!
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
I've got my 2007 and 2008 imperial stouts, but I don't think I want to part with any bottles for comps.
- maltbarley
- Posts: 2408
- Joined: Thu Dec 08, 2005 9:31 am
- Location: Orange, CA
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
Maybe we should enter the club RIS.
- brew captain
- Posts: 1158
- Joined: Sat Oct 01, 2005 8:41 am
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
Tim - that is a good idea if it has come around enough to be worthy. How was it at the last sampling?
Cheers!
Cheers!
- maltbarley
- Posts: 2408
- Joined: Thu Dec 08, 2005 9:31 am
- Location: Orange, CA
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
I've never tried it, but maybe Tyler will stop in and comment.
- backyard brewer
- Posts: 3774
- Joined: Fri Feb 18, 2005 5:38 pm
- Location: Orange County, CA
- Contact:
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
Boy that's a broad competition for a COC. Usually they are only on category or a small handful at most.
Re: AHA Club Only Competition Schedule
I can vouch for BC's Tripel. I can't recall all the specific flavors as it was back in early January when I tasted it, but I recall it was very nice. Sorry for the lack of a better review.brew captain wrote:I must admit that I have a very nice Tripel that is almost a year old, but I am dubious that I have enough left to fill even one bottle let alone two. I swear that keg should have blown ten pints ago, but it keeps on keeping on.
Of course now that I need to fill a couple bottles I am sure it will blow foam the instant I depress the tap handle next...
Anybody else got a conforming beer?
Cheers!
Jon